• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Home
  • Firm Overview
    • COVID-19 Response
  • Attorneys
    • Richard Cordell Low
    • Matthew A. Grosh
    • Brad Zuke
  • Staff
    • Diane Coyle
    • Susan Dreyer
    • Erin Hirschmann
    • Christina Warfel
    • Jeanna Johnson
  • Blog
  • Articles
  • Contact
Herr & Low Logo

We Take It Personally.

  • PH: 717-397-7544

Judge slams insurer’s conduct in decades-long legal battle

A judge has accused an insurer of endangering public safety and covering up evidence in a car crash lawsuit.

Insurer accused of covering up evidence and endangering public safety

A 1996 motor vehicle crash that led to nearly 20 years of legal battles between the crash victims and their insurer has resulted in the insurer being ordered to pay $18 million in punitive damages, according to the Reading Eagle. The case, Berg v. Nationwide, is believed to be the largest punitive damages amount awarded in Pennsylvania history. The Berks County judge in the case severely criticized the conduct of the insurance company, accusing it of endangering the lives of drivers and pursuing a policy that put profits before public safety.

Car ‘totaled’

The crash occurred in 1996 when the plaintiff’s Jeep Grand Cherokee was struck by a Subaru. According to the Philadelphia Inquirer, a mechanic decided that the Jeep would need to be completely replaced. Without telling the plaintiffs, however, the insurer insisted on a second opinion to avoid replacing the vehicle. Instead of paying the $25,000 to replace the Jeep, the insurer paid only half that amount for repairs.

A whistleblower who worked for the garage, however, later told the plaintiffs that their vehicle was unsafe and would come apart in a crash. The discovery led to years of legal claims. The Berks County judge in this case said the insurer put the lives of the plaintiffs at risk and endangered the safety of other drivers on the road.

Strategy to fight small claims

The insurer, however, instead of admitting any wrongdoing and replacing the car, spent the next decades spending $3 million defending itself when it could have just spent $25,000 to replace the vehicle in the first place. According to court documents, the insurer had a policy of aggressively defending itself against small claims in the belief that most plaintiffs would simply give up rather than spend years pursuing a claim.

The Berks County judge, in awarding the $18 million punitive damages to the plaintiffs, also accused the insurer of covering up evidence, concealing information from the plaintiffs, and hiding photos of the crash scene. Sadly, one of the plaintiffs, a woman who was in the Jeep during the collision that led to this lawsuit, lost her battle to cancer shortly before the ruling. The insurer has vowed to appeal.

Motor vehicle accidents

While a motor vehicle accident is traumatic in itself, in many cases, as the above story shows, the real battle comes when victims try to fight for the claims that they are rightfully due. Insurers, as seen above, may go to seemingly absurd lengths to avoid paying out on a claim.

In the case above, the insurer was finally held to account because of the tenacious and dedicated work of personal injury lawyers, who stuck with the case for years despite the aggressive tactics adopted by the insurer. This story shows just how important it is for anybody injured in a car crash to have the best legal representation possible. With proper legal guidance, victims of a car accident will have the help they need when pursuing the compensation and justice they deserve.

Keywords: motor vehicle accident, car crash, right to recovery, insurance

Follow Our Firm

  • Follow us on Facebook
  • Follow Us On LinkedIn

Primary Sidebar

HOW CAN WE HELP?

Tell Us About Your Legal Issue
  • close
    The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.
    Privacy Policy
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Secondary Sidebar

  • Personal injury
    • Personal Injury
    • Premises Liability
    • Negligent Lighting And Security
    • Elevator Injuries
    • Retail Store Accidents
    • Slip and Fall Accidents
    • Brain Injuries
    • Spinal Cord Injuries
    • Soft Tissue Injuries
    • Burn Injuries
    • Wrongful Death
    • Car Accidents
    • Fatal Auto Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents: Insurance Issues and Medical Bills
    • Truck Accidents
    • Bicycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • T-Bone Accidents
    • Bus Accidents
    • Rear-End Collisions
    • Head-On Collisions
    • Taxi Accidents
    • Drunk Driver Accidents
    • Distracted Driving Accidents
  • Worker’s Compensation
    • Worker’s Compensation
    • Work-Related Injuries
    • Construction Accidents
    • Ladder Accidents
    • Scaffolding Accidents
    • Farm Accidents
    • Heavy Equipment And Machinery Accidents
    • Work Vehicle Accidents
  • Business Law
    • Business Law
    • Small Business Formations And Acquisitions
    • Contract Law
  • Nonprofits And Tax-Exempt Organizations
  • Commercial and Residential Real Estate
  • Mediation
  • Estate Planning
    • Estate Planning Law
    • Becoming A Power Of Attorney For Elderly Parents
    • Estate Administration
    • Probate Litigation

Herr & Low, P.C.
234 North Duke Street
Lancaster, PA 17602
Phone: 717-397-7544
Fax: 717-397-8227
Lancaster Law Office Map

Attorneys

Richard Cordell Low
rlow@herrlow.com

Matthew A. Grosh
mgrosh@herrlow.com

Brad Zuke
brad@herrlow.com

Herr & Low Logo

We Take It Personally.

Herr & Low, P.C., represents clients throughout central Pennsylvania, including individuals, families and businesses in Lancaster, Manheim Township, Ephrata, Lititz, Elizabethtown, Gap, Millersville, Columbia, Manheim and Strasburg, as well as clients in communities in Lancaster County, York County, Chester County, Dauphin County and Lebanon County.
Copyright ©2021 Herr & Low, P.C. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer Site Map Privacy Policy